Manuel Lugo is in a New York prison. This is not history. It is happening now. years. Still inside. Still fighting for justice. Read why the evidence demands his release →
Contact

Not a cold case — a man in a cell today

Bronx · 1994 · Carlos Ventura homicide

32 years. For a murder he says he didn’t commit.

Manuel Lugo was in his early twenties when the state took him away. The eyewitness later recanted. Another man’s admissions are at the heart of defense filings—while Manuel, still in prison this morning, waits on slow paper and public indifference. This site is the evidence, linked to sources so you can believe it—and then do something.

— days in custody—and counting. Approximate from mid‑1995; confirm exact dates in official records.

See why the evidence is clear → Tell your rep: reopen this case Write Manuel on JPay today →
Every serious claim sourced Filings, transcripts & news archives Written so anyone can help him
0
Years of Manuel’s life inside
1994
The year the case swallowed his twenties
0
Times advocates say the confessed figure was charged as the shooter — the record →
Manuel Lugo in a green uniform, seated—campaign photograph.

“I have spent the past 27 years in prison for a crime I did not commit or witness.”

Jump to: Evidence Act now Full timeline Documents Videos Media JPay Blog
New York Daily News coverage, April 2015: family and supporters urge a Bronx judge to reopen Manuel Lugo’s case; rally photograph by Michael Schwartz. Archive screen capture from FreeLugo.com.

Real people, real years

They showed up while Manuel stayed inside

This fight was never only paper—it is families and neighbors in the cold, talking to reporters, holding signs season after season while Manuel aged behind bars. The photo is from 2015; the need for a fair hearing is still urgent today.

Image from archived NY Daily News article (Apr. 14, 2015). See primary link and full archive before republishing.

See the coverage Help Manuel now →

Core issues

Why this conviction should be overturned

Manuel is not a footnote—he is a person the state still holds. Each card is a reason advocates say the case failed him, backed by filings and reporting. Open a card for citations. Critical means highest concern; structural and context fill in the rest.

Defense filings and affidavits describe changed testimony over time. Compare original trial testimony with later sworn statements in Evidence: The false eyewitness.

Source: Post-conviction affidavits and defense summaries (see Legal documents).

Advocates argue the confession context undermines the theory of Manuel Lugo’s culpability. See Evidence: The confessed killer and the Mena profile.

Source: Plea papers involving related defendants and defense memoranda (library summaries in Legal documents).

Timeline of professional sanctions and reporting is summarized in Evidence: Prosecutorial misconduct.

Source: News articles and disciplinary summaries linked from Media coverage.

Read names, documents, and context in Other witness recantations and Key figures.

Source: Filed affidavits listed in Legal documents.

See The Wilfredo Roman acquittal for narrative and citations.

Source: Trial reporting and court summaries (media index).

What happened

Year by year — the case that won’t let him go

Filter by phase. Every box is another year Manuel wasn’t free. The full interactive timeline expands each chapter with links and detail.

Homicide of Carlos Ventura; Bronx investigation and early case theories.

Trial; Manuel Lugo convicted—co-defendant Wilfredo Roman acquitted.

Angel Otero recantation and related post-conviction filings.

Additional affidavits (e.g., Santos, Vivian Otero) and defense motions.

Continued litigation, media coverage, and advocacy visibility.

Open the full timeline — every date →

The evidence

It points away from Manuel — read it yourself

Short summaries open in modals; the full evidence file walks every theme with citations. This is what supporters want judges, journalists, and strangers to see.

Modal

False testimony & coaching

How defense teams frame suggestive procedures and changed witness accounts—and why courts demand record-specific proof.

Modal

Confession vs. trial theory

Compare statements attributed to Mena with the narrative used against Lugo at trial.

Analysis

Expert commentary

Eyewitness science, disclosure obligations, and cumulative error—framed for this record.

Read the blog analysis

Comparison: Mena vs. Lugo (advocacy summary)

Ulysses Mena (as described in public filings)

  • Linked to confession-related evidence in defense materials
  • Charging and parole status discussed in case summaries
  • Detailed profile: Key figures

Manuel Lugo

  • Convicted; maintains factual innocence
  • Multiple post-conviction affidavits cited in defense filings
  • Profile: Key figures

Witness recantations (conceptual timeline)

Trial testimony (1990s) → post-conviction affidavits (2000s+) → ongoing litigation. Exact dates appear in timeline filters under “evidence.”

Trial testimony themes

  • Confident identification
  • Narrative supporting the prosecution theory
  • Tested by cross-examination in the trial record

Post-conviction affidavit themes

  • Recantation or revised account
  • Allegations of pressure or suggestive practice
  • Weighed by courts for credibility—never automatic proof

This is a neutral roadmap for reading the record, not a substitute for transcripts and filed affidavits. Continue in Evidence: Angel Otero and the document library.

Watch: Noticias SIN / Justice Denied (2015)

Two-part coverage of Manuel Lugo’s case with Alicia Ortega / Noticias SIN, preserved from the original campaign site. More outlets and article screenshots: Media archive.

If the first video does not load, open it on YouTube.

If the second video does not load, open it on YouTube.

September 28, 2015 — Alicia Ortega / Noticias SIN / Justice Denied. More outlets and screenshots: Media & video coverage. Original campaign page (legacy site).

Bronx locations map

Geography is illustrative; verify addresses in primary records before reuse.

Open larger map (OpenStreetMap)

The people

Who was really there that night — and after

Names you’ll hear in every motion and story: Manuel first, then witnesses, co-defendants, and the trial team. Manuel’s photo is shared with permission; others use neutral avatars where we don’t publish private images. Deeper bios on Key figures.

  • Manuel Lugo seated, wearing a green uniform, looking toward the camera. Campaign photograph.

    Manuel Lugo

    Convicted; maintains factual innocence. Center of post-conviction advocacy.

    His statement Profile →

  • Angel Otero

    Trial eyewitness; later recantation and coaching claims in filings.

    Profile →

  • Ulysses Mena

    Linked to confession-related summaries in defense materials.

    Profile →

  • Wilfredo Roman

    Co-defendant acquitted at trial—contrast with Lugo’s conviction.

    Profile →

  • Lenny Sepulveda

    Plea-resolved role described in public filings; compare to trial theory.

    Profile →

  • ADA Dawn Florio

    Trial prosecutor; later professional issues reported in the press.

    Profile →

Relationship snapshot: Homicide investigation → trial team (Florio / Marcus) → witnesses (Otero, others) → co-defendants (Lugo, Roman) → related pleas (Sepulveda) → post-conviction affidavits. See full diagram-style narrative on the figures page.

All key figures & judge

Act now

Manuel needs you to do one of these things today

Manuel has been writing versions of the same plea for 32 years. He has watched motion after motion while the world outside moved on. Cases like his turn when ordinary people get loud—when inboxes flood, when letters arrive on JPay, when shares force someone to look. None of this is abstract. He wakes up in a cell today. Pick one step below; most take less than five minutes.

Then: share what you verified, contact an official, and—if you can—reach him through the state’s approved channels.

Ways to help

Petition

No petition is linked on this site yet. When the campaign publishes a live petition, this block will be updated with the official URL.

Search Change.org

Donate to innocence work

Printable case summary

Open the summary page, then use your browser’s Print → Save as PDF to download a file for officials.

Open printable summary

Support Manuel directly

Two ways to reach him today — a message or money in his account — using JPay (common for New York State). JPay does not offer a link with his ID pre-filled: you create a free account, then search by New York and his current DIN. Always confirm the DIN and facility first.

Verify DIN & facility (NYS DOCCS) Open JPay to write him → Full instructions →

Write Manuel a letter

JPay delivers your message electronically. Many facilities process incoming messages within about 48 hours, but timing varies. You’ll need a free JPay account, then find Manuel using New York and the DIN from the official lookup.

What to enter in JPay (from DOCCS)
  • State: New York
  • Facility: Use the facility name exactly as it appears on his current DOCCS profile (it can change after a transfer).
  • DIN: His Department Identification Number from the same lookup—copy it carefully; JPay must match DOCCS.
  1. Create a free account at JPay.com
  2. Open Email → select New York → enter his DIN
  3. Write your message — each email uses a JPay “stamp” (about $0.35 is typical; fees are set by JPay)
  4. Send
Write to Manuel on JPay →

Put money in Manuel’s account

Funds go to his commissary account for approved items (food, hygiene, phone, postage—per facility rules). Transfers run through JPay; service fees apply.

Same inmate details

New York + DIN + facility as shown in DOCCS Inmate Lookup.

  1. Go to JPay Send Money
  2. Select New York, enter his DIN, confirm his name
  3. Choose an amount and pay by card
Send money via JPay →

Note: JPay requires a free account. Fees for stamps and transfers go to JPay (not “cash” to Manuel). If he does not appear under JPay for New York, the facility may use another vendor—try ConnectNetwork or recheck DOCCS.

Postal mail (no JPay)

You can send a paper letter using the mailing address on his DOCCS profile. Include a return address if you want a reply. Mailing-line template →

Letter template — elected official

Dear [Official Name],

I am writing regarding Manuel Lugo, convicted in connection with the 1994 homicide of Carlos Ventura in the Bronx. I am concerned about documented post-conviction affidavits, eyewitness recantation issues, and questions surrounding charging decisions involving other individuals.

I respectfully ask that you review publicly available court filings and support appropriate procedural fairness measures, including access to forensic testing and evidentiary hearings where warranted.

Sincerely,
[Your Name]
[Your Address]
Email assembly info (example)

Share this page

Email updates

There is no mailing-list signup on this site yet. Use the contact form to reach the campaign or ask to be notified when a list is available.

Contact the campaign

Journalists, attorneys, and researchers: use the form for inquiries. Not legal advice.